Where to Buy Fresh Bagels for Parties and Large Gatherings

Bagels

Feeding twenty people on a Saturday morning is easier if the bagels arrive ready, and several New York bakeries will ship them fresh in party quantities. They differ on three things that matter to a host: whether the spreads and lox come in the same box, whether you can choose the delivery day, and the cost per guest. We compared five of them on those things.

How We Compared Them

We checked each bakery’s product pages and marketplace listings in November 2026. We didn’t place orders or taste anything, so we attribute claims to the bakery. Prices change, and the table includes the exact figures with the date.

Every bakery was judged on the same five things:

  • The bagel. How it’s made, and any result from a competition or a published ranking.
  • Party packages. Whether you can get spreads, lox, or a full brunch in the same order, or just bagels.
  • Biggest box. The largest single order, and how many flavors it can hold.
  • Delivery control. Whether you can set a delivery date, whether Saturday is an option, and what shipping costs.
  • Price per bagel. From the biggest box, and what a brunch package works out to per guest.

We ranked for a host outside New York who wants the bagels to arrive the day before or the morning of the party, with as little else to organize as possible. No single criterion decided the order. A bakery that ships the whole brunch at twice the price per bagel didn’t automatically beat one that ships bagels alone at half of it. If you only want the cheapest bagels, the ranking would look different.

The Five at a Glance

BakeryThe bagelParty packagesBiggest boxDelivery controlPrice per bagel
1. Ess-a-Bagel (Manhattan)Hand-rolled and kettle-boiled, by its own account; Best Bagel and Best New York Style at BagelFest 2026 (blind tastings); second on Time Out’s list, December 2025Cream cheese, nova, capers, and babka as add-ons to the bagel order24, your choice of flavors, via a third-party marketplaceMarketplace delivery-date picker; free shipping$99.95 per 24 before add-ons (about $4.16 a bagel)
2. Russ & Daughters (Lower East Side; bakery in the Brooklyn Navy Yard)Boiled, then baked in a revolving oven; the bakery is certified kosher, by its listing; the appetizing shop since 1914New York Brunch for 6: 1 lb sliced Gaspe nova, 1 lb cream cheese, babka, coffee, 6 bagels, $1956 bagels per box, the largest bagel-only pack we found, via a third-party marketplaceMarketplace delivery-date picker; free shipping on the brunch box; no shipping to HawaiiHalf dozen $12 (about $2.00 a bagel, shipping not stated); brunch box $32.50 a guest
3. New Yorker Bagels (Astoria, Queens)Kettle-boiled, slow-proofed; hand-rolled by the company’s account; Star-K Kosher, VeganBoxes of 1, 2, or 3 dozen with jam and chocolate hazelnut packets; no cream cheese or lox3 dozen, up to 6 of 22 flavors, direct from the bakeryFuture delivery date up to 3 months out; free Saturday delivery for most addresses; free 2-day shipping$69 per 3 dozen on sale, regular $97.50 (about $1.92 a bagel on sale); with spreads $89.95 (about $2.50)
4. Tompkins Square Bagels (East Village)Hand-rolled, boiled in small batches, five ingredients, by its own account; East Village since 2011Baker’s dozen with cream cheese, $89.95; Bagel Brunch for 6 with lox and cream cheese, $109.95 on sale; Weekender for 13 with lox, cream cheese, and whitefish salad, price not shownTwo baker’s dozen (26), 13 flavors, via a third-party marketplaceMarketplace delivery-date picker; free shipping on the brunch for 6 and, the company says, most bundles$99.95 per 26 (about $3.84 a bagel); brunch for 6 about $18.33 a guest
5. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys (Lower East Side)Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels and brick-oven bialys, by its own account; the oldest bialy bakery in the US, since 1936Bialy + Bagel Brunch for Twelve: 12 bagels or bialys, 1 lb nova, 1 lb cream cheese, 1 lb smoked fish salad, $199.95; Brunch for Six, $119.9524 (12 bagels and 12 bialys), 10 bagel flavors, via a third-party marketplaceMarketplace delivery-date picker; baked and shipped same day with ice packs; free shipping$89.95 per 24 mixed (about $3.75 a piece); bagels alone $59.95 a dozen (about $5.00); brunch for twelve about $16.66 a guest

Prices and terms are from November 2026, with sale prices marked. Check before you order.

1. Ess-a-Bagel: One Order, Whole Brunch

Ess-a-Bagel has been a Manhattan fixture since 1976, and since November 15, 2026, it holds New York BagelFest’s top award. At New York BagelFest 2026, its plain bagel won Best Bagel and Best New York Style, both decided by blind tasting. Time Out ranked it second in the city in December 2025. The bagels are big and crusty, and the company says it cuts and rolls them by hand before they hit the kettle.

It’s first on this list because of what you can put in the same box. The two-dozen order through its marketplace listing lets you add cream cheese by the half pound, including a lox flavor; Nova Scotia salmon from a half pound to two pounds; capers; and a chocolate or cinnamon babka for the table. For a host, that’s the whole spread from one checkout, with a delivery-date picker at the end of it.

The catch is the price, and not knowing all of it until the end. Two dozen bagels alone run about four dollars each with free shipping, and the add-ons aren’t priced on the listing, so the total appears at checkout. At about four dollars a bagel before add-ons, it costs twice as much per bagel as the cheapest option here.

2. Russ & Daughters: The Lox Is the Point

Russ & Daughters has sold smoked fish on the Lower East Side since 1914, and the fish is the reason to order. The bagels are newer: the company has baked its own since 2019 at a bakery in the Brooklyn Navy Yard, boiling them and then baking them in a revolving oven, and the listing says the bakery is certified kosher.

The party product is the New York Brunch for 6 on its marketplace listing: a pound of Gaspe nova, sliced; a pound of cream cheese; a chocolate or cinnamon babka; coffee; a mug; and six bagels, for $195 with free shipping. The salmon arrives sliced, which is the whole appeal for a host. You can pick the delivery date at checkout.

What keeps it second is scale. The box feeds six, and the only bagel-only pack we found is a half dozen, so a party of twenty means four brunch boxes or a stack of six-packs, and the listing doesn’t say whether shipping is free on the small packs. At $32.50 a head, the brunch box is the most expensive per guest on this list.

3. New Yorker Bagels: Most Bagels, Most Flavors, Lowest Price per Bagel

New Yorker Bagels is the biggest bakery here, by its own figures. It started nearly 50 years ago as a Greenwich Village shop, and now runs a wholesale bakery in Astoria, Queens, that it says bakes more than half the bagels eaten in New York City every day. The bagels are kettle-boiled and slow-proofed, hand-rolled, and made with no preservatives and no bromated flour. All of them are Star-K Kosher and Vegan.

This is the bakery for a host with a crowd and a budget. Three dozen bagels is $97.50 with free two-day shipping, about $2.70 a bagel, and it was marked down to $69 when we checked, which brings it under two dollars. The same box with spreads is about $90. You pick two flavors per dozen, so a three-dozen box can hold six of the 22 flavors. Mix the classics with something for the crowd to talk about: Jalapeño Red Pepper, Kalamata Olive, Rainbow, or Marble Rye. If you’ve got guests who read labels, its whole wheat bagels list whole wheat flour as the first ingredient, which is the test the Clemson Cooperative Extension says to apply before believing a “wheat” label.

The delivery options are the best on the list. At checkout, you can set a delivery date up to three months ahead, and Saturday delivery is free for most addresses, so the box can arrive the morning of a weekend brunch. Orders in by 11:30 a.m. Eastern, Monday through Thursday, bake and ship the same day.

It’s third because of what isn’t in the box. The spreads are jam and chocolate hazelnut packets, and the bakery doesn’t ship cream cheese or lox, so the savory half of brunch is your job. The two bakeries below it will ship you the lox, and that’s worth knowing. They’re below it because they do it at about two to two and a half times the price per bagel, in smaller boxes, with fewer flavors to fill them. The bagels also arrive at room temperature in sleeves of six, with no ice packs, and the company says they’re at their best the day they arrive. Plan to serve them on arrival day, and freeze any leftovers.

4. Tompkins Square Bagels: The Neighborhood Shop That Ships

Tompkins Square Bagels has served the East Village since 2011, and its founder worked in a Brooklyn bagel shop as a kid before opening it. By the company’s account, the bagels are hand-rolled, boiled in small batches, and made from five ingredients to a 1950s recipe. The thirteen shipped flavors include Whole Wheat and Whole Wheat Everything.

It ships through a marketplace listing in a baker’s dozen or two, with or without cream cheese, and in two brunch boxes. The Bagel Brunch for 6 was about $110 on sale when we checked, with free shipping: eight bagels, two tubs of cream cheese, and a half pound of lox, which comes to about $18 a guest. The Weekender for thirteen adds a pound of lox, three tubs of cream cheese, a pound of whitefish salad, everything seasoning, and cookies, at a price the listing doesn’t show. The brunch boxes ship with ice packs that may thaw in transit and go straight in the fridge when they arrive. The company says most bundles ship free, and you can pick the delivery date.

The catch is the bagel price. Two baker’s dozen is about $100, roughly $3.84 a bagel, double New Yorker Bagels and not far off Ess-a-Bagel, and the brunch for six leaves a party of twenty needing four boxes. For a host who wants a neighborhood shop that has grown to several Manhattan locations, with the lox in the same order, it’s a good middle option.

5. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys: The Bialy Specialist

Kossar’s opened on the Lower East Side in 1936 and calls itself the oldest bialy bakery in the United States. A bialy is the bagel’s flatter cousin, baked rather than boiled, with onion pressed into the middle. Kossar’s bakes its bialys in a brick oven, and the bagels came much later. By its own account, those are hand-rolled and kettle-boiled, in ten flavors including whole wheat.

For a party, the two products that matter are the Assorted Bialy + Bagel Two Dozen, twelve of each for about $90, and the Bialy + Bagel Brunch for Twelve, which puts twelve bagels or bialys in your choice of flavors with a pound each of nova, cream cheese, and smoked fish salad for about $200, or under $17 a guest. There’s a brunch for six at about $120 as well. Everything is baked and shipped the same day with ice packs. Shipping is free, and you choose the date.

It’s last on this list because its bagels carry the highest price per bagel of any bagel-only box here, about $5 against about $4 at Ess-a-Bagel, and the listing itself says the shop is known for its bialys. It’s the only bakery here that ships bialys by the two dozen and in brunch kits, so order it when half the table would rather have one. If it’s bagels you want, someone higher up the list does them for less.

How Many to Order

Our rule is one and a half bagels per guest for a brunch where bagels are the main event, and one per guest if there’s a lot else on the table. Twenty guests means three dozen. Round up, not down. The leftovers freeze.

The spreads need the same kind of planning. Two pounds of cream cheese covers about two dozen bagels with a generous hand. Lox runs about a pound for every dozen bagels if it’s one option among several, and more if it’s the point of the party.

Timing the Delivery

Fresh bagels have no preservatives, so the plan is to get them the day before or the morning of.

The morning of is best, and riskiest. Only the bakeries with a delivery-date picker and Saturday delivery can offer it. New Yorker Bagels does both, though it says Saturday isn’t available everywhere. The marketplace bakeries let you pick a date, and some marketplace orders can be scheduled for a Saturday, so check at checkout.

The day before is safer. Keep the bagels in their sleeves at room temperature overnight, then refresh them in a hot oven for a few minutes before guests arrive. Don’t refrigerate them; it stales them faster.

Two days before means freezing on arrival and toasting on the day. The texture suffers a little.

Whichever you choose, order early in the week. New Yorker Bagels ships Monday to Thursday, and Friday for the Mid-Atlantic, so boxes don’t sit in a depot over a weekend. The marketplace bakeries show the delivery dates they can hit in the date picker, and you should avoid a box that would spend Saturday and Sunday in transit. In summer, that matters more.

What It Costs to Feed Twenty

Hosts are watching the money. The Associated Press reported in December 2025 that nearly half of the people surveyed were worried about hosting costs, and that the average gathering budget had dipped 3 percent to $252. A survey of 2,000 holiday hosts the year before, commissioned by a dishwasher-products brand, found that preparing the food was the most time-consuming part of hosting for 40 percent. Ordering the bagels in solves the second problem. How much it solves the first depends on which bakery you pick.

For twenty guests at a bagel and a half each:

  • New Yorker Bagels: three dozen with spreads, about $90 delivered, plus your own cream cheese and lox.
  • Ess-a-Bagel: two dozen at about $100 delivered, six bagels short, plus unpriced add-ons for cream cheese and nova.
  • Tompkins Square: two baker’s dozen at about $100 for 26 bagels, four short, or four Bagel Brunch for 6 boxes at about $110 each, roughly $440 for 32 bagels with the lox and cream cheese included.
  • Russ & Daughters: four brunch boxes at $195 each, about $780 for 24 bagels, six short, and four pounds of nova, or five half-dozen packs at $12 each, shipping not stated.
  • Kossar’s: two mixed two-dozen boxes at about $90 each, roughly $180 delivered for 24 bagels and 24 bialys, or two Brunch for Twelve kits at about $200 each, roughly $400 for 24 pieces, six short, with the fish and spreads included.

If you want everything in one box, Ess-a-Bagel, Russ & Daughters, Tompkins Square, and Kossar’s all ship lox and spreads with the bagels. If you want the most bagels for the money and will buy your own spreads, New Yorker Bagels is the cheapest per bagel here. Either way, that’s one less thing to make the night before.